Executives of My Big Coin to settle with CFTC, agreeing to pay almost $26 million in penalties.

In a landmark decision by a Massachusetts federal court, My Big Coin Pay, Inc. and its executives have been hit with $25.8 million in fines and restitution for fraudulent activities, marking a pivotal moment in cryptocurrency regulation. This case highlights the Commodity Futures Trading Commission's robust stance against deceit in the crypto sector, setting a precedent for future regulatory actions.

Ivy Tran

June 13, 2025

In a recent ruling that underscores the increasingly stringent regulatory scrutiny within the cryptocurrency sector, My Big Coin Pay, Inc., My Big Coin, Inc., and their executives, Mark Gillespie and John Roche, have been ordered by a Massachusetts federal court to pay a hefty sum in fines and restitution. The penalty, totaling approximately $25.8 million, follows a Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) investigation into fraudulent activities linked to the My Big Coin (MBC) cryptocurrency offering.

The court's decision, which includes $19.32 million in civil penalties and $6.44 million in restitution to defrauded investors, represents a significant enforcement action by the CFTC. Gillespie, Roche, and their associated companies were also permanently barred from trading and other market-related activities under the CFTC's jurisdiction. This outcome not only emphasizes the financial repercussions of deceiving investors but also represents a broader trend of regulatory agencies taking decisive actions against malpractices in the burgeoning crypto space.

The case against My Big Coin involved allegations that from January 2014 to June 2017, the operators misled investors by making false claims about the cryptocurrency's backing by gold and its liquidity on trading platforms. Such deceptive practices not only swindled individuals out of over $6 million but also posed a broader threat to the integrity of the digital asset market. As reported by CoinTelegraph, this deceit undermined the trust necessary for a functioning and fair market.

Earlier, Randall Crater, another operator involved with MBC, faced a court order to pay $7.6 million to defrauded investors and was sentenced to over eight years in prison. This series of legal actions highlights a growing pattern: regulatory bodies like the CFTC are not only punishing fraudulent activities but are also setting precedents that could deter future misconduct in the crypto industry. Such actions are vital for protecting investors and maintaining market integrity, especially in an industry that has been historically plagued by a lack of transparency and regulatory oversight.

This case also illustrates the CFTC's commitment to enforcing its regulations amidst the rapid growth of digital assets. CFTC’s Chairman Rostin Behnam previously emphasized that the agency would not provide an "easy street" for cryptocurrency operations, reflecting a stern stance on compliance and enforcement. This resonates with the broader regulatory dialogue surrounding cryptocurrencies, highlighting a need for robust frameworks that ensure these technologies flourish without enabling financial crime.

From a broader perspective, the My Big Coin settlement acts as a cautionary tale for the crypto industry. It tells us that as the cryptocurrency market matures, the leniency once afforded to nascent tech innovations is swiftly being supplanted by rigorous, informed, and sometimes punitive regulation. For companies operating in this space, compliance should not be an afterthought but a foundational component of their business operations.

Furthermore, this judgment might influence the future design and operation of cryptocurrencies. Potential and existing operators are now more aware that they operate under the watchful eye of powerful financial regulators. As we've seen in other advancements, integrating robust compliance measures and transparent practices is not merely legal prudence; it's a strategic imperative that can define a cryptocurrency’s ability to operate successfully in regulated markets.

In conclusion, the hefty fines and penalties imposed on the executives and entities associated with My Big Coin serve as a stark reminder and deterrent for the cryptocurrency industry. They underscore the critical importance of upholding integrity and transparency within this space, aligning with both ethical practices and regulatory standards to foster a secure and robust digital asset market.

Sign up to Radom to get started